Will you rate this photo I took? Please...?

I am new at photography with NO professional training or education, all my knowledge is based from online research, advice and inspiration...

Please leave feedback negative or positive or advice and rate on a 1-5 scale 1 being lowest and 5 being highest.

I do admire advice from all people professional or not.

Thank You

Photo 1 is of Bridge structure.

http://trisha-87.deviantart.com/art/Brid...

Photo 2 is of Downtown at night.

http://trisha-87.deviantart.com/art/Gold...

I like them both.

The symmetrical balance in the first shot is always a crowd pleaser. IF you can find a way to make it an asymmetrically balanced shot you'll be better off but if you're not good at doing this, it's alot harder and more easy to ruin.

For the second image did you mean to have a harsh edge where the color and b&w meet? I ask because the color almost looks brushed on. If you haven't already done so, you may want to elect to soften the edge on the mask if you did this in Photoshop and compare them to see which you prefer.

HTH

Wow! I loved them both! I think I liked the bridge one better though, it was very unique. I liked the coloring in the second one, it was pretty cool, but I wasn't sure if you captured the feel of the city. I'm not even sure if that was what you were going for, I just think that it needed more personality, but what do I know? I thought that they were terriffic photos and you should definitely continue with photography!
1st pic-4
2nd pic-3

I'm no expert.

I think they're both quite good. You have talent.

The first one is the best IMO. The composition is perfect. It makes an otherwise unremarkable subject interesting.

Wow. I think those pictures are magnificent. Keep going!

5 for both!!

I really like the first one...now you just need to come up with a good name for it...if I were you...enter this one in some magazine photo contest...it's that good. Only thing I think could made it a little better is if you had a tall ladder to take the picture from.....it would have given it a better endless mirror effect.

I am no professional but I have to say these are amazing; I especially like the contrast black and white of the bridge structure it is exquisite-really, all the dimensions and the crop is spectacular.
The downtown at night is also very nice with the black and white then the dramatic flow with contrast of the lights.
They both look like something in an art exhibit or in a magazine. You have a talent, don't stop, I will be seeing your work in magazines and books I am sure. Thanks for sharing

The first one is really good.

The second one I think should be cropped so that the the color of the car lights go almost corner to corner. crop off most of the sky, and part of the empty parking on the right.

phot 1 ..interesting...about a 3
phot 2... shopped..i like the colours on the road and BW BG..3.8

Now you are tlaking.... Downtown at night.....beautiful 10/10 but the bridge, lacks contrast 1/5

luv the bridge shot i give it a 4

the bridge is just so so (2/5)

the downtown image was pretty nice. (3.5 out of 5) my first reaction was "wicked".